Supreme Court upholds anesthesiologist’s liability for mother’s brain injury
The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed both appeals in Hemmings v. Padmore, leaving an anesthesiologist liable for a patient’s brain injury.
In this article & details
The Supreme Court of Canada upheld an Ontario anesthesiologist’s liability for a patient’s permanent brain injury following an emergency caesarean delivery. In its October 23 ruling in Hemmings v. Padmore, the court dismissed both the anesthesiologist’s appeal and the family’s appeal seeking to restore findings against an obstetrician and the hospital.
The patient, Sophia Hemmings, sustained severe brain damage after complications from anesthesia. The trial judge held anesthesiologist Neil Jamensky, obstetrician Lloyd Gregory Padmore and the hospital liable. Ontario’s Court of Appeal overturned the findings against Padmore and the hospital in 2024 and left the judgment against Jamensky in place.
Judges split over responsibility for the injury
The court’s majority said evidence at trial supported the conclusion that Jamensky’s negligence caused the injury. It found flaws in the trial judge’s analysis of whether the injury would have occurred without the nurse’s negligence and whether the nurse and Padmore could reasonably have foreseen the injury.
Three judges would have restored the trial judgment against Padmore. Chief Justice Richard Wagner would have allowed Jamensky’s appeal. The court docket records that both appeals were dismissed without costs and the file was closed November 3.
Writing after the judgment, lawyer Megan Chan said the reasons distinguish whether negligence caused the harm from whether that harm was reasonably foreseeable. She noted that an act can be a necessary cause of an injury even when several factors contributed to it.
References
- Hemmings v. Padmore, 2026 SCC 34 — Case in Brief — Supreme Court of Canada, Decision, October 23, 2026
- Case information and docket, 41350 — Supreme Court of Canada, Court record
- “Legal Causation” Swept into the Dustbin in Favour of “Remoteness” — Rogers Partners LLP, Analysis by Megan Chan, October 29, 2026
Discussion
0 commentsJoin the discussion. Anyone can read the comments. To comment, log in or create a free individual account.
No comments yet.